Should You Tell Your Kids Santa Isn’t Real?

Why I say “not quite,” and what to say when they ask

Should you tell your kids Santa isn’t real?

My answer might surprise you: No. Not because I want you to lie, but because I don’t think it’s true.

The two bad options

Most parents I’ve talked to feel torn: lie and hope they don’t find out from someone else, or tell the truth and steal the magic of Christmas forever. I used to think those were the only choices too.

Then I researched where Santa actually came from, and I was blown away.

There’s a third option

When they’re ready to hear it, not before they ask, tell them the actual truth: Santa is real, even more real than you ever could have imagined.

The Santa most of us grew up with is the watered-down, commercialized version, so much smaller than his very real story. The truth has been lost, twisted, and mixed up over many centuries. If someone has told your child that Santa isn’t real, it’s because no one taught them the whole story.

Why I’m not rushing

Some of the most important ideas are the most difficult to learn. Parents wait to explain them until their children are ready to understand. I don’t think this one needs to be rushed either.

If your child hasn’t asked, they may not be ready. I’m waiting for the moment the wondering starts, so I can hand them something I already wrote for exactly that moment.

What to say when they ask

Start with a boy named Nikolaos, born around the year 270 in what is now Turkey. When his parents died and left him a fortune, he gave it away in secret so no one could repay him. That child’s choice changed the whole world, and the spirit he started has kept Santa real for centuries.

I’ll share a word-for-word script in my next post on answering the question.

Santa is real because of us

His spirit needs hearts to feel through, hands to give through, and bodies to move through. When your child learns this, they don’t lose Santa. They become part of him.

Magic doesn’t happen to you. It happens through you.

Two books for two moments

Still believing? Read Yes, Virginia, There Is a Santa Claus together. It’s my adaptation of the classic letter, written to be read aloud to kids who still believe.

Get Yes, Virginia, There Is a Santa Claus →

Starting to wonder? Keep The True Story of Santa Claus ready for the day they ask. It tells the real history of Nikolaos and answers the question honestly, without breaking the magic.

Get The True Story of Santa Claus →

A free way to start today

You don’t need either book to teach your kids that they have the power to create magic, miracles, and joy for others. My free Miracle Maker printable walks kids through planning their own secret act of kindness.

Print it out, grab your kids, and let them decide how they'll make an ordinary day extraordinary for someone else. That's how Santa’s spirits continues to be real. That’s how his miracles and generosity have continued and will continue for millennia. Not because we tell kids to believe, but because we show them how to become the reason someone else does.

Next up

The Origins of the Advent Calendar

Subscribe to my Substack @LaurenMartinBooks so you don’t miss it. 🎄

Next
Next

Chimneys and Stockings: Where These Traditions Really Began